Phoebe looked at him. There was fear in her eyes and she shook her head.

"Cole? That spell, it made people sing their true feelings... Kiki and lana and I figured that part out. If you didn't hate me enough to want me dead, you never would have said it." She swallowed. "I know I hurt you, and I knew you hated me. I guess I just didn't expect you to hate me enough to want me dead."